Intel® Quartus® Prime Pro Edition User Guide: Design Optimization

Download PDF
ID 683641
Date 9/26/2022
Public

A newer version of this document is available. Customers should click here to go to the newest version.

Document Table of Contents
Document Table of Contents x
1. Answers to Top FAQs 2. Design Optimization Overview 3. Optimizing the Design Netlist 4. Netlist Optimizations and Physical Synthesis 5. Area Optimization 6. Timing Closure and Optimization 7. Analyzing and Optimizing the Design Floorplan 8. Using the ECO Compilation Flow 9. Intel® Quartus® Prime Pro Edition Design Optimization User Guide Archives A. Intel® Quartus® Prime Pro Edition User Guides
2. Design Optimization Overview x
2.1. Initial FPGA Device Considerations 2.2. Initial Compiler Settings 2.3. Optimization Trade-Offs and Limitations 2.4. Design Visualization and Optimization Tools 2.5. Design Optimization Overview Revision History
2.1. Initial FPGA Device Considerations x
2.1.1. Device Migration Considerations
2.2. Initial Compiler Settings x
2.2.1. Initial I/O Assignment Guidelines 2.2.2. Initial Timing Constraint Guidelines
2.3. Optimization Trade-Offs and Limitations x
2.3.1. Area Reduction Trade-Offs 2.3.2. Critical Path Delay Reduction Trade-Offs 2.3.3. Power Consumption Reduction Trade-Offs 2.3.4. Compilation Time Trade-Offs
2.4. Design Visualization and Optimization Tools x
2.4.1. Design Visualization Tools 2.4.2. Design Optimization Tools
3. Optimizing the Design Netlist x
3.1. When to Use the Netlist Viewers: Analyzing Design Problems 3.2. Intel® Quartus® Prime Design Flow with the Netlist Viewers 3.3. RTL Viewer Overview 3.4. Technology Map Viewer Overview 3.5. Netlist Viewer User Interface 3.6. Schematic View 3.7. Cross-Probing to a Source Design File and Other Intel® Quartus® Prime Windows 3.8. Cross-Probing to the Netlist Viewers from Other Intel® Quartus® Prime Windows 3.9. Viewing a Timing Path 3.10. Optimizing the Design Netlist Revision History
3.3. RTL Viewer Overview x
3.3.1. Maximizing Readability in RTL Viewer 3.3.2. Running the RTL Viewer
3.5. Netlist Viewer User Interface x
3.5.1. Netlist Navigator Pane 3.5.2. Properties Pane 3.5.3. Netlist Viewers Find Pane
3.6. Schematic View x
3.6.1. Display Schematics in Multiple Tabbed View 3.6.2. Schematic Symbols 3.6.3. Select Items in the Schematic View 3.6.4. Shortcut Menu Commands in the Schematic View 3.6.5. Filtering in the Schematic View 3.6.6. View Contents of Nodes in the Schematic View 3.6.7. Moving Nodes in the Schematic View 3.6.8. View LUT Representations in the Technology Map Viewer 3.6.9. Zoom Controls 3.6.10. Navigating with the Bird's Eye View 3.6.11. Partition the Schematic into Pages 3.6.12. Follow Nets Across Schematic Pages
4. Netlist Optimizations and Physical Synthesis x
4.1. Physical Synthesis Optimizations 4.2. Applying Netlist Optimizations 4.3. Scripting Support 4.4. Netlist Optimizations and Physical Synthesis Revision History
4.1. Physical Synthesis Optimizations x
4.1.1. Disabling or Enabling Physical Synthesis Optimization 4.1.2. Physical Synthesis Options
4.2. Applying Netlist Optimizations x
4.2.1. WYSIWYG Primitive Resynthesis
4.3. Scripting Support x
4.3.1. Synthesis Netlist Optimizations 4.3.2. Physical Synthesis Optimizations
5. Area Optimization x
5.1. Resource Utilization Information 5.2. Optimizing Resource Utilization 5.3. Scripting Support 5.4. Area Optimization Revision History
5.1. Resource Utilization Information x
5.1.1. Flow Summary Report 5.1.2. Fitter Reports 5.1.3. Design Assistant Recommendations 5.1.4. Analysis and Synthesis Reports 5.1.5. Compilation Messages 5.1.6. Chip Planner Visualization
5.2. Optimizing Resource Utilization x
5.2.1. Resource Utilization Issues Overview 5.2.2. I/O Pin Utilization or Placement 5.2.3. Logic Utilization or Placement 5.2.4. Routing
5.2.2. I/O Pin Utilization or Placement x
5.2.2.1. Guideline: Modify Pin Assignments or Choose a Larger Package
5.2.3. Logic Utilization or Placement x
5.2.3.1. Guideline: Optimize Source Code 5.2.3.2. Guideline: Optimize Synthesis for Area, Not Speed 5.2.3.3. Guideline: Restructure Multiplexers 5.2.3.4. Guideline: Perform WYSIWYG Primitive Resynthesis with Balanced or Area Setting 5.2.3.5. Guideline: Use Register Packing 5.2.3.6. Guideline: Remove Fitter Constraints 5.2.3.7. Guideline: Flatten the Hierarchy During Synthesis 5.2.3.8. Guideline: Re-target Memory Blocks 5.2.3.9. Guideline: Use Physical Synthesis Options to Reduce Area 5.2.3.10. Guideline: Retarget or Balance DSP Blocks 5.2.3.11. Guideline: Use a Larger Device 5.2.3.12. Guideline: Reduce Global Signal Congestion 5.2.3.13. Guideline: Report Pipelining Information
5.2.4. Routing x
5.2.4.1. Guideline: Set Auto Packed Registers to Sparse or Sparse Auto 5.2.4.2. Guideline: Set Fitter Aggressive Routability Optimizations to Always 5.2.4.3. Guideline: Increase Router Effort Multiplier 5.2.4.4. Guideline: Remove Fitter Constraints 5.2.4.5. Guideline: Optimize Synthesis for Routability 5.2.4.6. Guideline: Optimize Source Code 5.2.4.7. Guideline: Use a Larger Device
5.3. Scripting Support x
5.3.1. Initial Compilation Settings 5.3.2. Resource Utilization Optimization Techniques
6. Timing Closure and Optimization x
6.1. Optimize Multi Corner Timing 6.2. Optimize Critical Paths 6.3. Optimize Critical Chains 6.4. Design Evaluation for Timing Closure 6.5. Timing Optimization 6.6. Periphery to Core Register Placement and Routing Optimization 6.7. Scripting Support 6.8. Timing Closure and Optimization Revision History
6.2. Optimize Critical Paths x
6.2.1. Viewing Critical Paths
6.3. Optimize Critical Chains x
6.3.1. Viewing Critical Chains
6.4. Design Evaluation for Timing Closure x
6.4.1. Review Messages 6.4.2. Evaluate Fitter Netlist Optimizations 6.4.3. Evaluate Optimization Results 6.4.4. Evaluate Resource Usage 6.4.5. Evaluate Other Reports and Adjust Settings Accordingly 6.4.6. Evaluate Clustering Difficulty 6.4.7. Revise and Recompile
6.4.4. Evaluate Resource Usage x
6.4.4.1. Evaluate Global and Non-Global Usage 6.4.4.2. Evaluate Routing Usage 6.4.4.3. Evaluate Wires Added for Hold
6.5. Timing Optimization x
6.5.1. Correct Design Assistant Rule Violations 6.5.2. Implement Fast Forward Timing Closure Recommendations 6.5.3. Review Timing Path Details 6.5.4. Try Optional Fitter Settings 6.5.5. Back-Annotate Optimized Assignments 6.5.6. Optimize Settings with Design Space Explorer II 6.5.7. I/O Timing Optimization Techniques 6.5.8. Register-to-Register Timing Optimization Techniques 6.5.9. Metastability Analysis and Optimization Techniques
6.5.2. Implement Fast Forward Timing Closure Recommendations x
6.5.2.1. Retiming Limit Details Report 6.5.2.2. Fast Forward Timing Closure Recommendations
6.5.2.1. Retiming Limit Details Report x
6.5.2.1.1. Using the Retiming Limit Details Report
6.5.2.2. Fast Forward Timing Closure Recommendations x
6.5.2.2.1. Generating Fast Forward Timing Closure Recommendations 6.5.2.2.2. Implementing Fast Forward Recommendations
6.5.3. Review Timing Path Details x
6.5.3.1. Report Timing 6.5.3.2. Report Logic Depth 6.5.3.3. Report Neighbor Paths 6.5.3.4. Report Register Spread 6.5.3.5. Report Route Net of Interest 6.5.3.6. Report Retiming Restrictions 6.5.3.7. Report Pipelining Information 6.5.3.8. Report CDC Viewer 6.5.3.9. Timing Closure Recommendations 6.5.3.10. Global Network Buffers 6.5.3.11. Resets and Global Networks 6.5.3.12. Suspicious Setup 6.5.3.13. Auto Shift Register Replacement 6.5.3.14. Clocking Architecture
6.5.3.10. Global Network Buffers x
6.5.3.10.1. Source Location 6.5.3.10.2. Insertion Delay 6.5.3.10.3. Fan-Out 6.5.3.10.4. Global Signal Assignment
6.5.4. Try Optional Fitter Settings x
6.5.4.1. Optimize Hold Timing 6.5.4.2. Fitter Aggressive Routability Optimization
6.5.6. Optimize Settings with Design Space Explorer II x
6.5.6.1. DSE II Computing Resources 6.5.6.2. DSE II Optimization Parameters 6.5.6.3. DSE II Result Management 6.5.6.4. Running DSE II
6.5.7. I/O Timing Optimization Techniques x
6.5.7.1. I/O Timing Constraints 6.5.7.2. Optimize IOC Register Placement for Timing Logic Option 6.5.7.3. Fast Input, Output, and Output Enable Registers 6.5.7.4. Programmable Delays 6.5.7.5. Use PLLs to Shift Clock Edges 6.5.7.6. Use Fast Regional Clock Networks and Regional Clocks Networks 6.5.7.7. Spine Clock Limitations
6.5.8. Register-to-Register Timing Optimization Techniques x
6.5.8.1. Optimize Source Code 6.5.8.2. Improving Register-to-Register Timing 6.5.8.3. Physical Synthesis Optimizations 6.5.8.4. Set Power Optimization During Synthesis to Normal Compilation 6.5.8.5. Optimize Synthesis for Performance, Not Area 6.5.8.6. Flatten the Hierarchy During Synthesis 6.5.8.7. Set the Synthesis Effort to High 6.5.8.8. Duplicate Registers for Fan-Out Control 6.5.8.9. Prevent Shift Register Inference 6.5.8.10. Use Other Synthesis Options Available in Your Synthesis Tool 6.5.8.11. Fitter Seed 6.5.8.12. Set Maximum Router Timing Optimization Level 6.5.8.13. Register-to-Register Timing Analysis
6.5.8.8. Duplicate Registers for Fan-Out Control x
6.5.8.8.1. Manual Register Duplication 6.5.8.8.2. Automatic Register Duplication: Estimated Physical Proximity 6.5.8.8.3. Automatic Register Duplication: Hierarchical Proximity
6.5.8.13. Register-to-Register Timing Analysis x
6.5.8.13.1. Tips for Analyzing Failing Paths 6.5.8.13.2. Tips for Analyzing Failing Clock Paths that Cross Clock Domains 6.5.8.13.3. Tips for Critical Path Analysis 6.5.8.13.4. Tips for Creating a .tcl Script to Monitor Critical Paths Across Compiles 6.5.8.13.5. Global Routing Resources 6.5.8.13.6. Register RAMS and DSPs
6.6. Periphery to Core Register Placement and Routing Optimization x
6.6.1. Setting Periphery to Core Optimizations in the Advanced Fitter Setting Dialog Box 6.6.2. Setting Periphery to Core Optimizations in the Assignment Editor 6.6.3. Viewing Periphery to Core Optimizations in the Fitter Report
6.7. Scripting Support x
6.7.1. Initial Compilation Settings 6.7.2. I/O Timing Optimization Techniques 6.7.3. Register-to-Register Timing Optimization Techniques
7. Analyzing and Optimizing the Design Floorplan x
7.1. Design Floorplan Analysis in Chip Planner 7.2. Defining Logic Lock Placement Constraints 7.3. Defining Virtual Pins 7.4. Using Logic Lock Regions in Combination with Design Partitions 7.5. Creating Clock Region Assignments in Chip Planner 7.6. Scripting Support 7.7. Analyzing and Optimizing the Design Floorplan Revision History
7.1. Design Floorplan Analysis in Chip Planner x
7.1.1. Starting the Chip Planner 7.1.2. Chip Planner GUI 7.1.3. Viewing Design Elements in Chip Planner 7.1.4. Finding Design Elements in the Chip Planner 7.1.5. Exploring Paths in the Chip Planner 7.1.6. Viewing Assignments in the Chip Planner 7.1.7. Viewing High-Speed and Low-Power Tiles in the Chip Planner 7.1.8. Viewing Design Partition Placement
7.1.3. Viewing Design Elements in Chip Planner x
7.1.3.1. Viewing Architecture-Specific Design Information in Chip Planner 7.1.3.2. Viewing Available Clock Networks in Chip Planner 7.1.3.3. Viewing Clock Sector Utilization in Chip Planner 7.1.3.4. Viewing Routing Congestion in Chip Planner 7.1.3.5. Viewing I/O Banks in Chip Planner 7.1.3.6. Viewing High-Speed Serial Interfaces (HSSI) in Chip Planner 7.1.3.7. Viewing Source and Destination Nodes in Chip Planner 7.1.3.8. Viewing Fan-In and Fan-Out in Chip Planner 7.1.3.9. Viewing Immediate Fan-In and Fan-Out in Chip Planner 7.1.3.10. Viewing the Selected Contents in Chip Planner 7.1.3.11. Viewing the Location and Utilization of Device Resources in Chip Planner 7.1.3.12. Viewing Module Placement by Cross-Probing to Chip Planner
7.1.4. Finding Design Elements in the Chip Planner x
7.1.4.1. Find Options (Chip Planner Search)
7.1.5. Exploring Paths in the Chip Planner x
7.1.5.1. Analyzing Connections for a Path 7.1.5.2. Locate Path from the Timing Analysis Report to the Chip Planner 7.1.5.3. Show Delays 7.1.5.4. Viewing Routing Resources
7.2. Defining Logic Lock Placement Constraints x
7.2.1. The Logic Lock Regions Window 7.2.2. Defining Logic Lock Regions 7.2.3. Customizing the Shape of Logic Lock Regions 7.2.4. Assigning Device Pins to Logic Lock Regions 7.2.5. Viewing Connections Between Logic Lock Regions in Chip Planner 7.2.6. Example: Placement Best Practices for Intel® Arria® 10 FPGAs 7.2.7. Migrating Assignments between Intel® Quartus® Prime Standard Edition and Intel® Quartus® Prime Pro Edition
7.2.2. Defining Logic Lock Regions x
7.2.2.1. Defining a Logic Lock Region in Chip Planner 7.2.2.2. Defining a Logic Lock Region from the Project Navigator 7.2.2.3. Defining Routing Regions 7.2.2.4. Defining Empty Logic Lock Regions 7.2.2.5. Defining Hierarchical Logic Lock Regions
7.2.2.1. Defining a Logic Lock Region in Chip Planner x
7.2.2.1.1. Logic Lock Region Properties 7.2.2.1.2. Snapping to a Region 7.2.2.1.3. Considerations for Auto Sized Regions
7.2.3. Customizing the Shape of Logic Lock Regions x
7.2.3.1. Adding a New Shape to a Logic Lock Region 7.2.3.2. Subtracting Shape from Logic Lock Region 7.2.3.3. Merging Logic Lock Regions 7.2.3.4. Defining Noncontiguous Logic Lock Regions
7.4. Using Logic Lock Regions in Combination with Design Partitions x
7.4.1. Viewing Design Connectivity and Hierarchy
7.5. Creating Clock Region Assignments in Chip Planner x
7.5.1. Creating Clock Assignments in Chip Planner 7.5.2. Resizing a Clock Assignment in Chip Planner 7.5.3. Moving a Clock Assignment in Chip Planner 7.5.4. Deleting a Clock Region Assignment in Chip Planner 7.5.5. Assigning a Clock Signal to a Clock Region in Chip Planner
7.5.1. Creating Clock Assignments in Chip Planner x
7.5.1.1. Clock Assignment Properties
7.6. Scripting Support x
7.6.1. Creating Logic Lock Assignments with Tcl commands 7.6.2. Assigning Virtual Pins with a Tcl command 7.6.3. Logic Lock Region Assignment Examples
8. Using the ECO Compilation Flow x
8.1. ECO Compilation Flow 8.2. ECO Tcl Script Example 8.3. Viewing ECO Compilation Reports 8.4. ECO Commands 8.5. ECO Command Limitations 8.6. Interactive ECO Fitting 8.7. Using the ECO Compilation Flow Revision History
8.4. ECO Commands x
8.4.1. ECO Command Quick Reference 8.4.2. make_connection 8.4.3. remove_connection 8.4.4. modify_lutmask 8.4.5. adjust_pll_refclk 8.4.6. modify_io_slew_rate 8.4.7. modify_io_current_strength 8.4.8. modify_io_delay_chain 8.4.9. create_new_node 8.4.10. remove_node 8.4.11. place_node 8.4.12. unplace_node 8.4.13. create_wirelut
8.6. Interactive ECO Fitting x
8.6.1. eco_load_design and eco_commit_design Commands
1. Answers to Top FAQs
2. Design Optimization Overview
3. Optimizing the Design Netlist
4. Netlist Optimizations and Physical Synthesis
5. Area Optimization
6. Timing Closure and Optimization
7. Analyzing and Optimizing the Design Floorplan
8. Using the ECO Compilation Flow
9. Intel® Quartus® Prime Pro Edition Design Optimization User Guide Archives
A. Intel® Quartus® Prime Pro Edition User Guides

6.4.4.3. Evaluate Wires Added for Hold

During routing the Fitter may add wire between register paths to increase delay to meet hold time requirements. The Fitter reports how much routing delay was added in the Estimated Delay Added for Hold Timing report. Excessive additional wire can indicate an error with the constraint. The cause of such errors is typically incorrect multicycle transfers between multi-rate clocks, and between different clock networks.

Review the specific register paths in the Estimated Delay Added for Hold Timing report to determine whether the Fitter adds excessive wire to meet hold timing.

Figure 23. Estimated Delay Added for Hold Timing Report

An example of an incorrect constraint which can cause the router to add wire for hold requirements is when there is data transfer from 1x to 2x clocks. Assume the design intent is to allow two cycles per transfer. Data can arrive any time in the two destination clock cycles by adding a multicycle setup constraint as shown in the example: 

set_multicycle_path -from 1x -to 2x -setup -end 2

The timing requirement is relaxed by one 2x clock cycle, as shown in the black line in the waveform in the figure.

Figure 24. Timing Requirement Relaxed Waveform
The default hold requirement, shown with the dashed blue line, can force the router to add wire to guarantee that data is delayed by one cycle. To correct the hold requirement, add a multicycle constraint with a hold option. 
set_multicycle_path -from 1x -to 2x -setup -end 2
set_multicycle_path -from 1x -to 2x -hold -end 1

The orange dashed line in the figure above represents the hold relationship, and no extra wire is required to delay the data.

The router can also add wire for hold timing requirements when data transfers in the same clock domain, but between clock branches that use different buffering. Transferring between clock network types happens more often between the periphery and the core. The following figure shows data is coming into a device, a periphery clock drives the source register, and a global clock drives the destination register. A global clock buffer has larger insertion delay than a periphery clock buffer. The clock delay to the destination register is much larger than to the source register, hence extra delay is necessary on the data path to ensure that it meets its hold requirement.

Figure 25. Clock Delay

To identify cases where a path has different clock network types, review the path in the Timing Analyzer, and check nodes along the source and destination clock paths. Also, check the source and destination clock frequencies to see whether they are the same, or multiples, and whether there are multicycle exceptions on the paths. Finally, ensure that all cross-domain paths that are false by intent have an associated false path exception.

If you suspect that routing is added to fix real hold problems, you can disable the Optimize hold timing advanced Fitter setting (Assignments > Settings > Compiler Settings > Advanced Settings (Fitter) > Optimize hold timing). Recompile the design with Optimize hold timing disabled, and then rerun timing analysis to identify and correct any paths that fail hold time requirements.

Note: Disable the Optimize hold timing option only when debugging your design. Ensure to enable the option (default state) during normal compiles. Wire added for hold is a normal part of timing optimization during routing and is not always a problem.
Level Two Title