World War II, the fall of the Soviet Union, and 9/11 are all important turning points in the development of the world in which we live. What led to these pivotal moments in history? In this unit, students evaluate what they believe are the three most important turning points in European history from 1500–1939. Support for students’ judgments come from their research. Students use the Showing Evidence Tool to organize three claims and the evidence to support them, and participate in a mock trial to determine the most important turning point in European history.
View how a variety of student-centered assessments are used in the Turning Points in History Unit Plan. These assessments help students and teachers set goals; monitor student progress; provide feedback; assess thinking, processes, performances, and products; and reflect on learning throughout the learning cycle.
NOTE: This unit can be implemented as a culminating activity after studying key periods in European history.
Before the unit begins, provide each student with a journal to use throughout the learning cycle to record thoughts and responses to questions.
Write on the board the Essential Question, How did we get here from there? To help students make a personal connection, first ask them to reflect on the question and how it relates to their lives. Ask students, What events have led them to where they are today? Allow students time to respond in their journals and then ask volunteers to share and discuss their responses. Next, pose the question again and ask students to now answer the question in relation to the study of history. Guide students to think about the cause-and-effect nature of historical events, and give examples of how the outcomes of some events can dramatically change the course of history (for example, Pearl Harbor, Hitler attacking Russia in violation of the Nazi-Soviet Non-Aggression Pact, and so forth). Use a graphic organizer, such as a flowchart, to offer a visual representation of these examples.
Describe or review (depending on when in the unit is implemented) some of the key periods in European history from 1500–1939, such as the Reformation, Enlightenment, and Industrial Revolution periods. Make sure to distinguish the differences between a specific event (Waterloo) and the more general concept of a period (Renaissance). Lead a discussion about some of the important time periods in European history. Begin to define the idea of turning points in history, and ask students to brainstorm the types of events they think can be turning points. The National History Day Web site* states that a turning point can be:
Pose the Unit Question, How can we determine the most important turning points in the history of modern Europe? Have students propose some pivotal events in European history using the planning guide. Encourage students to share their thoughts as you record their responses on the board. Make sure students think critically about the impact of the events they choose and what factors contributed to the development of the events. Students should present a description of the events, but also draw conclusions about how the events affected individuals, communities, nations, or the world. Point out that each event listed is a starting point in answering the Essential Question, and often the paths “from there to here” include many complex events and issues. Allow time for students to record their thoughts in their journals.
Introduce students to the Showing Evidence Tool by exploring the Try the Tool demonstration space together. Discuss the sample case together or create a sample project and show students how to add, describe, and rate evidence and claims. Model how student teams will peer review each other’s work. Also, show the Comments feature, and agree on how it will be used. This feature can provide valuable insight into students’ thinking.
Hold a discussion around the idea of reliable evidence. Have students ask themselves the following questions when rating the reliability of an evidence source:
Before proceeding with the next activity, click here to set up the Turning Points in History project in your workspace. Have students log into their Showing Evidence team spaces. Assign students to work with a partner. Instruct students to choose three separate events that they think are the most important turning points in European history. Each event becomes a claim in the Showing Evidence workspace. Outline parameters for the amount of evidence needed for each claim. For example, students must find at least five pieces of evidence that support the claim and three pieces of evidence that weaken the claim. Remind students that evidence must be researched from reliable sources and must not be based on the students’ opinions. Distribute the argumentation rubric and explain to students that they should use the rubric as a guide while they work with Showing Evidence. As teams work, use the evaluative checklist to observe and assess the evaluative thinking of students.
After students complete the initial research stage, use the teacher workspace in Showing Evidence to assign each pair of students a peer team to review. Have student pairs use the peer review checklist to read and evaluate the claims of the team assigned to them and make constructive comments and corrections where needed to the claims and evidence. Students can comment on the work by requesting clarification of evidence, pointing out where claims are unclear, indicating where facts or assumptions are questionable, and correcting distortions of opposing points of view again using the argumentation rubric as a guide.
Use the Comments feature to give feedback, redirect effort, suggest new avenues of study, or ask for clarification about a team's thinking. When the review process is complete, give the students time to make adjustments and corrections based on the comments of their peer review team.
The Showing Evidence Tool space below represents one team's investigation in this project. You can double-click on the evidence to read the team's descriptions.
Project Name: Turning Points in History (Click here to set up this project in your workspace)
Prompt: What are the three most important turning points in European History?
Explore an interactive demo.
Bring the class back together and make a list on the board of all of the claims made by the student teams. Have each team give a short multimedia presentation detailing their claims. After the presentations, guide students through the process of determining which of the claims are the most important. Have the class reach consensus before a claim’s position on the list can be finalized. (Alternately, this activity could be conducted using the Visual Ranking Tool.)
Announce that a mock trial will be conducted between the two claims that the class consensus judged to be the most important. Assign students to courtroom roles, such as lawyers on the legal team representing each claim, expert witnesses, and jury members. Use the Mock Trial Guide* (PDF; 52 pages) to support the implementation of the trial. Share the mock trial rubric with students, so they are aware of the expectations for this performance assessment. Act as judge and manage the trial, ruling on objections raised by the legal teams and deciding if evidence is of high enough quality to be submitted to the “court.”
After the conclusion of the mock trial, ask each student to fill out a self reflection. The reflections give students an opportunity to reflect on their individual performances as well as the performance of their team as they prepared for and participated in the mock trial.
Revisit the Essential Question, How did we get here from there? Allow students time to reflect individually in their journals. Then, in small groups, have students discuss the question in relation to what they have learned with their research and mock trial. Bring the discussion back to the whole class and give students an opportunity to share what they talked about in their small groups.
Robert McCraw teaches European History and World History in McKinney, Texas. He participated in the Intel® Teach Program, which resulted in this idea for a classroom project. A team of teachers expanded the plan into the example you see here.
Grade Level: 9-12
Subject: Social Studies
Topics: European History
Higher-Order Thinking Skills: Argumentation, Investigation, Evaluation
Key Learnings: Turning Points, Argumentation Skills, Persuasive Speaking, Historical Research
Time Needed: 8-10 hours
Background: Texas, United States